Two SG2 Rules Errors/Questions

2 posts ยท Jun 12 2003 to Jun 12 2003

From: Allan Goodall <agoodall@a...>

Date: Thu, 12 Jun 2003 09:46:17 -0500

Subject: Two SG2 Rules Errors/Questions

I found an error in the SG2 observation rules. According to the rules text, if
you get a minor success when spotting a hidden marker and the marker is a
dummy, the marker is _not_ revealed. Instead the other person is told
that there is no unit there (the marker could therefore be a dummy, a booby
trap, a mine, etc.) However, the little blurb in the box says that the dummy
marker
_is_ removed from play.

How do you play it? I have always used the text as written, not the little
blurb (in most cases I treat the blurb as just "help" text, though in the case
of the IAVR it is the main text that has the IAVR Firepower die wrong while
the blurb is correct). Is this how you play?

Also, I noticed that the Regrouping action isn't mentioned in the list of
available actions. I assume that Regrouping can not be done while suppressed?

From: Yves Lefebvre <ivanohe@a...>

Date: Thu, 12 Jun 2003 13:09:19 -0400

Subject: Re: Two SG2 Rules Errors/Questions

> At 09:46 AM 2003-06-12 -0500, you wrote:

I think I would use the text version. Else, a minor success would means
that you know there is something dangerous there anyway (mine/booby
trap), so it is almost equivalent to a major success. With the text version,
you will know there is no unit, but won't be sure it is a safe place to
go...

> Also, I noticed that the Regrouping action isn't mentioned in the list

I don't know. Maybe it could be done but the new unit keep the suppression
from the most suppressed one?