PA & Such

2 posts ยท Feb 15 2001 to Feb 16 2001

From: Barclay, Tom <tomb@b...>

Date: Thu, 15 Feb 2001 15:06:30 -0500

Subject: PA & Such

[Bri] With a little previso. No small arms weapon (even those with
asterisk (*) next to them) can have NO effect, except supperssion, agianst
Class-2
armor or better (SG p.37).

[Tomb] No small arms can have NO effect? Ergo all small arms have at
least some effect against class 2 armour? <I think this is wrongly stated>

 And there are not too many armor class-1 tanks
(at least in DS2). So you may want to go back to having the PA have a heavy
weapon or a larger mix of the AT variant of your PA.

[Tomb] I think you could define anything as a "heavy weapon" or "point
fire" variant that could affect tanks. I think a good justification is the ESU
PA carrying a "point fire" railgun which I believe can probably punch into a
tank. And GMS/P have a d12* impact and I'm _quite_sure_ these are meant
to be able to attack things like a tank.

[Tomb] The limitation you are referring to (I had thought) applied only
to normal small arms (such as the FSE rifle, etc). They are meant to have
limited anti-armour capability versus soft targets or armour-1 targets,
but none vs. heavier armour. Whereas anything with an asterisk (such as a IPG
or GMS) is actually meant to have a chance (though a slight one) versus larger
vehicles.

If not, my IPG AT section looks pretty stupid... (2 x Infantry Plasma Gun with
D12* impact). I think it can attack armour 2 and greater targets (though D12*
isn't a big threat even on major impacts to anything greater than armour 2).

If I'm wrong, someone please straighten me out.

From: Brian Bell <bkb@b...>

Date: Fri, 16 Feb 2001 09:37:08 -0500

Subject: RE: PA & Such

I did state it wrong. It should say 'Small arms (even those with asterisks)
can have NO effect, except suppression, against armor class 2 or greater'.

It appears that I did read this wrong. Weapons with asterisks do work against
all armor levels.

However, I would be opposed to "upgrading" other weapons to point-fire
status. Doing so usually would mean that the support weapon becomes more
effective than the equivalent Heavy weapon (with basic fire control) due to
the Firepower rating and better rating against infantry. If you upgrade a
SAW or Rotary SAW to point fire, it would be a RFAC/1. If you upgrade
the
Gauss SAW, it would be a GAC/1.

-----
Brian Bell bkb@beol.net
http://www.ftsr.org
-----

> -----Original Message-----