[OT]: Wing Commander Re: Sorry guys should have guessed

3 posts ยท Jun 30 1999 to Jun 30 1999

From: Doug Evans <devans@n...>

Date: Wed, 30 Jun 1999 08:07:43 -0500

Subject: [OT]: Wing Commander Re: Sorry guys should have guessed

***
The movie was half-way decent...  if you were familiar with the setting
and
the plot-line fo the games.  I had a lot of co-workers go to it, and
never having played the game, thought it sucked, while when I saw it, I
thought it
was pretty good (albiet a tad soap-opera-ish), but when I looked at it
without backup of the knowledge of the game setting, I realised that it
didn't make a very good stand-alone movie.  Oh, and they screwed up the
ship designs too... No consistency with the game there, but I suppose that
much
can be over-looked.
***

Wow, my experience was just the opposite. I've never played, and appreciated
the movie far more than the players that went. 'They didn't look ANYTHING LIKE
K'ilrathi!!!'

Definitely mindless mind candy; I'd say it was good for getting space battle
fever for FT without having much for scenario grist.

Also, I've been impressed to see the action figures remaindered already.
I really like the K'ilrathi, but they are maybe 1/2-2/3 current GI Joe
size,
so too small to mix with Joe's unless you run them pussy-cat size, and
GIANT
for SGII-to-WH40K size ranges. Might play well with green soldiers of
the
near 1/35th variety, tho'.

The_Beast

From: Buddy Chamberlain <buddy@m...>

Date: Wed, 30 Jun 1999 09:22:12 -0400

Subject: Re: [OT]: Wing Commander Re: Sorry guys should have guessed

You are right, they did a number on the Kilrathi, too. I forgot that. I
think the Kilrathi looked more real and life-like on the third WC game
than in the movie.

Action figures??? Where?!?! I've never seen them...

God bless,
- Buddy

---------------------------------------------
Get paid for surfing the Web! (I'm dead serious!) www.alladvantage.com
Referral #: BXL-474
---------------------------------------------
[quoted original message omitted]

From: Dean Gundberg <dean.gundberg@n...>

Date: Wed, 30 Jun 1999 11:01:50 -0500

Subject: RE: [OT]: Wing Commander Re: Sorry guys should have guessed

Actually 'Wing Commander' will be available on video in the US next week (July
6th).

I saw it in the theater for the SW Episode 1 trailer and since it does have
space battles. I had many of the same problems with it but there were some
good points. Space did look deep the capital ships looked OK but why no decent
beauty shot of the Tiger's Claw? (a slow panning shot of the ship so we can
get a good look at it). I did like the fact that they had some very
submarine-like scenes and the Captain was played by Jurgen Pruchnow
(sp?)
from 'Das Boot'.