[OT] Battlecruisers vs. battleships

The action I wanted to see was a hypothetical Dec 10th, 1941 engagement
between the Prince of Wales and the Repulse against the Haruna and the Kongo
(both originally BCs, later converted to fast battleships). I have

wargamed this action once (using Raider Operations - ask me about
multiplayer Internet naval warfare offlist) and the Japanese BCs seemed
fairly effective - although a lucky torpedo strike left the Prince of
Wales fighting alone in very short order. I'll try the scenario again and hope
the RN can dodge torpedoes.

> Eric Foley wrote:

> That may be true... except for the fact that the three battlecruisers

I've run that scenario four times, using both Seekrieg and Command at Sea. The
honors are even, two wins each. In all cases, the win went to the side that
had the best tactics (in my judgement anyhow).
[quoted original message omitted]