From: Thomas Barclay <Thomas.Barclay@s...>
Date: Mon, 11 Mar 2002 11:02:45 -0500
Subject: Nukes vs. Tunnels --> Flame wars, your country needs YOU!
Derek said: As for this thread, in TomB's defense I think he was just showing us something could be interesting seeings as we WARgame it just got out of hand from there. Tomb: Thanks Derek. I don't think there was an ounce of anti-American sentiment in anything I said, unless someone read something into it that was never intended (a common problem of the Internet and those with hair triggers...). I find it funny that anyone can think of nuclear weapons as "clean". (In a relative sense, small tactical weapons well might be.... but relative isn't always the important barometer!). That was about the extent of my comments. I refuse to dable in defending Canada versus ridicule from John or anyone else. Not because I do not value my country (I wore the uniform and was prepared to give all I had), but ultimately because this is not the forum and "mine is bigger than yours" ceased being interesting along about when I left Junior High. Besides, a closed mind is its own punishment. However, I do sympathize with your comment about some listers sentiments making the list toxic for people of certain persuasions (Muslim, French, Eastern European, etc.) I'm sure they _could_ just deal with it and have a thick skin, but why would they bother? And why should they have to? Is this really an appropriate locale for bigotry? (justified in someone's mind or not?). The Americans have a right to object to anti-Americanism (that isn't any better than any other style of bigotry). But I think blanket statements about any group do great injustice to individuals and reflect poorly on their orators (or writers in this instance). I'm sure there is an alt.politics.US.and.them or alt.bigotry or some such place for such infantile and inflammatory rhetoric. I'm just disappointed that we as a community seem to think _this_ is also an appropriate venue for such drivel. Tomb:( Sorry he started the thread, though didn't recognize the risk at the time