From: Michael Llaneza <maserati@e...>
Date: Fri, 31 May 2002 22:03:27 -0700
Subject: Re: Many things - mostly very late aviation
The Red Air Force had no chance to handle the Allied heavy bomber offensive. Their armies would have withered on the vine as heavy bombers smashed their supply lines and airfields. No tank fights well without gas. Both air forces were combat experienced, with a probable edge to the USAAF in training and doctrine [1]. Put the US had the P-80 coming on line, and the Meteor was ready for series production as well. The Soviets had a few dozen rocket interceptors in service, but not much prospect for a front line jet fighter anytime soon. Add airborne radar to the Allied technological advantage. Given air superiority there is every reason to believe that the Soviet tank corps could find themselves trapped at the end of a long and vulnerable supply line and without air cover. At least the Germans had the advantage of short supply lines. The Soviets could even stand to lose Siberia to American, British and Commonwealth troops intended for the invasion of Japan. Two million men thrown against the troops holding a static front against the Japanese. I give the honors to the Allies, with all of Eastern Europe and Siberia liberated by English speaking troops. That said, I must give the Red Air Force full credit for an excellent job in the role for which it was designed: close air support. I've recently acquired a healthy respect for the Reds in the air, I've been playing a lot of a Russian made flight sim. Even given a certain natural bias, just from the different perspective, the Russian aircraft perform well in all roles -- at least by the end of the war as the Luftwaffe had a notable advantage through 1942. They had an excellent ground attack plane in the Sturmovik, and fighters to escort it at low level and some to go up for air superiority and go after the mediocre bombers the Germans had. But nothing to cope with hundreds of P-80s in service by the end of 1945. And thousands in 1946. [1] I use doctrine to mean the rules, procedures, shared assumptions and philosophy of a military service as a finghting entity. That covers the range from line and column tactics to modern armored Maneuver Warfare, it's just what you call whatever it is that they actually do. > The Red Air Force was designed to provide close air