[GZG] A bit of PAU with Re:A Sad Day

2 posts ยท Apr 24 2011 to Apr 25 2011

From: Doug Evans <devans@n...>

Date: Sun, 24 Apr 2011 09:49:24 -0500

Subject: [GZG] A bit of PAU with Re:A Sad Day

Tom B wrote on 04/23/2011 05:47:46 PM:

Para 2
> As to whether the passing of Lis Sladen is an excuse for a 'best

We've had the occasional excuse, like feelings being crushed, to end one, but
otherwise, PLAY ON!

Para the first
> Yes, Ace was good. And I think I agree with your criteria. Being

Militant qualities, as well as 'too brainy' have actually tended to have
negative effects on a) the character's personality, and b) the interactions
with the Doctor. I'd have to say I think a fair amount of dependency, both to
keep us informed of the situation, and to keep us uninformed of the solution,
is required in a companion.

To quote myself off of LAF:

"Female companions have often been either scream queens, or stoically 'stiff
upper lip' strong. Sarah Jane always seemed to have just the right balance for
the drama, with a bit of extra sparkle. Many a talented and promising
following companion seemed to suffer by comparison. Case of 'they weren't bad;
she was just too good'...

Naturally, in my case, a bit unfair, really. She was my first. ;->=

Of course, condolences to Ms.Sladen's husband and daughter, but I hope
they find pleasure in world-wide fond remembrances. "

Note, I always rather assumed if I'd seen Troughton or Pertwee first, I would
never had appreciated 'that popinjay!'

> I disqualify K-9 because his presence didn't prevent another

I'd go with 'tool'; interactive sonic screwdriver, but I DO quibble.

> Most of the time, having one fleshy companion was all the doctor

He was, wasn't he? I think there were exceptions in the deep dark long ago,
but I can't name one.

Slightly better if, in injecting some tension, he/she's an obvious
traitor...

> Only solitary men know the full joys of friendship. Others have

Wow, quoting a Nebraska author! ;->=

Back to GZG, and FT:

> I thought the PAU bought the majority of it's ships (especially their

And my image was always NAC ships. I guess I always thought they looked
like assegai.  ;->=

If we get a few new PAU ships, and I'd suggest they'd definitely have at
the least a few smaller build-your-own, can they break with the current
designs that everyone but me prefers? A bit of sleek brick?

Wait, there's a new mystery fleet?

The_Beast

From: Indy Kochte <kochte@s...>

Date: Mon, 25 Apr 2011 15:25:12 -0400

Subject: Re: [GZG] A bit of PAU with Re:A Sad Day

_______________________________________________
Gzg-l mailing list
Gzg-l@mail.csua.berkeley.edu
http://mail.csua.berkeley.edu:8080/mailman/listinfo/gzg-lOn Sun, Apr 24,
> 2011 at 10:49 AM, Doug Evans <devans@nebraska.edu> wrote:

> > Yes, Ace was good. And I think I agree with your criteria. Being

I was never much of a Dr Who fan, and I attribute it to the scream queen
companions. Early on when I could have been hooked by the show, all I saw were
scream queens, which just turned me right off (I hate scream queens), so I
never bothered keeping up with it. With Christopher Eccleston coming on board
I gave it another go, and liked it much better. Liked Tenant, too, but the
current boy they have...I stopped watching again.

Wait, there's a new mystery fleet?
> [quoted text omitted]

Yeah. To me it looks like a much needed tech/design upgrade to the UNSC.

:-)

Mk