From: Dean Gundberg <dean.gundberg@n...>
Date: Fri, 19 Dec 97 09:39:46 -0600
Subject: Another Version of Cloaking
I have some rules for cloaking that are somewhat different than those being discussed. In converting ships from Starfleet Wars to FT, one of the races has an 'Invisibility Screen' but I was never happy with how it played. In order to get the effect I wanted, I came up with the following rules which fall kinda in-between the other cloaks. Basically when cloaked, the presence of the ship is known and its position is known (to some extent) but that is it. Information beyond the presence of the ship is unknown (size, class, etc). It could be a destroyer or it could be a dreadnought but there is no way to tell. The cloaking effects the fire control of the opposing ships so cloaked ships are fired on as if they were 2 times the actual distance away (14" actual distance, combat resolved as if the distance was 28") The cloaked ship can see out and can fire, but at a reduced level. Since the general rational for cloaking is that it takes lots of power, I could not have them fire as normal so only beam weapons can fired when cloaked but they fire as a beam battery one size smaller (A-batts fire as a B-batt with 2d6 to 12" and 1d6 to 24"). This results in the cloaked ship having the ability to fire at targets out to 24" with an A-batt but its opponents can only target it out to 18" with an A-batt. Thus the cloaked ship has a 6" band of immunity, if it can stay there. On the other hand, at a range of 6" or less, the cloaked ship only gets 2d6 to attack with its reduced A-batt, but the opponent now gets 3d6. In the end I think it can make some interesting scenarios where one side has several cloaked ships of unknown sizes. Are they all destroyers and the they are trying to bluff? Or are they all capital ships just waiting for you to close so they can de-cloak and open fire with all their weapons? I am planning a future PBeM game based on this. It also has some interesting campaign implications when the presence of ships are known, but not their size or type.