allan's arty

3 posts ยท Aug 3 2000 to Aug 4 2000

From: Barclay, Tom <tomb@b...>

Date: Thu, 3 Aug 2000 15:59:13 -0400

Subject: allan's arty

Allan, calm my brother!

My answer to you is this: Though I do not use arty much (I prefer TacAir
because it can be directed, controlled, and fought by the defender), I would
say all off table air strikes or fire missions arrive not at Box 1, but at the
Battle Area. If you want an immediate Fire Mission, you put it on the track at
Box 1, then at the end of the round it arrives at the Battle Area and hits
home. This might be platoon mortars or a registered, dedicated battery
attached at company level.

Just go with what makes the most fun - do you like your arty quick or
slow? Is anyone but you gonna notice?:)

Many scenarios I play involve Spec Forces or small underequipped troops on the
move. Arty is often not an option.

When my air units enter the board, I have AA small arms rules and
Anti-Air
GMS rules to deal with them. This makes them a fun part of the battle and I do
use confidence levels for them so they don't just route off the board.
(Generally, by the time someone gets around to dealing with the air units,
it involves laying an HKP/4 or a HEL/4 into them.... at which point they
blow up so morale isn't often a huge problem - though I've seen
GMS/P-Air
take them out too). Strangely, with Aliens VTOLs, the biggest danger zone is
the rear of the vehicle. So as long as it sits at the map edge front-on
to the hostiles, it has reasonable armour. If it turns away, it tends to take
a shot up the kilt... often terminal.

From: Kevin Balentine <kevinbalentine@m...>

Date: Thu, 3 Aug 2000 15:23:53 -0700 (PDT)

Subject: Re: allan's arty

I've been wanting to reply to this thread, but I left my rulebook at my
friend's house after our last game.

After reading what Tom wrote, I would say that I agree with him
wholeheartedly!

Arty arrives when it reaches the battle area.

> --- "Barclay, Tom" <tomb@bitheads.com> wrote:

From: Allan Goodall <agoodall@a...>

Date: Thu, 03 Aug 2000 21:00:48 -0400

Subject: Re: allan's arty

On Thu, 03 Aug 2000 15:59:13 -0400, "Barclay, Tom" <tomb@bitheads.com>
wrote:

> My answer to you is this: Though I do not use arty much (I prefer

Thanks Tom, Kevin and Brendan. This is what I figured. As I said, the rules
are actually written contradictory. I went to Andy Cowell's page for the SG2
errata and this isn't mentioned. It seemed obvious that it was an error and it
meant the Battle Area, but the problem was slightly compounded when you read
the rules on direct fire of artillery. You COULD run into people who argue
artillery hits on box 1, and everything else on the Battle Area.

At any rate, that's how I'd do it in my scenarios. For conventions, I like to
run with as close to "real" as I can.

Oh, and Tom, I'm running my "Operation: Dust Off" scenario at GenCon next
week. It involves an evac operation with ontable air support and
anti-air. I
mention it because I'm also going to run it at GZG-ECC. I'll post a
convention
write-up in about 11 days. *S*